Index Investing vs Stock Picking: The Math
A broad index provides a reference portfolio, making it possible to compare the outcome of selecting individual stocks with a less concentrated alternative.

A broad index provides a reference portfolio, making it possible to compare the outcome of selecting individual stocks with a less concentrated alternative. A fair comparison includes fees, dividends and the timing of contributions.
Write down a benchmark before measuring performance. Changing the comparison after seeing the result can make an ordinary outcome look like skill. Even a strong result over one short period says little about repeatability.








